7 Donations Thrift Stores Toss—Here’s What to Do Instead

Thrift Store Rejections

You need a thrift store shopping strategy. Understand what items are rejected for hygiene and safety reasons to make informed choices.

• Thrift stores reject items like used makeup and skincare for hygiene reasons.
• They toss out potential safety issues, like child car seats and strollers that may not be up to code.
• Items like reusable grocery bags are thrown out because they are considered clutter.

Meet the Expert

Try adding a shopping expert’s advice to your thrift store visits for better finds and insights.

• PJ Gach is a fashion, shopping, and thrifting expert who worked and volunteered in thrift stores for years.
• Cynthia Traxler is the founder of Review-Reuse-Repair.com.
• Marlise Kast-Myers is the owner of Brick n Barn antique shop that accepts donated items.

Car Seats and Strollers

Swap this for a certified safety car seat. Be cautious when considering used car seats and strollers for your child’s safety.

• Always check for safety compliance and recalls.
• Consider buying new for essential items like car seats.
• Research brands known for safety ratings.

Partially Used Cosmetics and Skincare

You need a hygienic approach when it comes to cosmetics. Only buy unopened products for safety.

• Avoid purchasing opened or partially used cosmetics.
• Check expiration dates on skincare products.
• Look for brands that offer safe formulations.

Bike Helmets

Invest in a new bike helmet for maximum safety. Used helmets may not offer the protection you need.

• Check for visible damage or wear.
• Look for safety certifications on helmets.
• Consider your head size for a proper fit.

Reusable Grocery Bags

Try adding a durable reusable grocery bag to your shopping routine. They are eco-friendly and practical.

• Choose bags made from sustainable materials.
• Opt for machine-washable options for easy care.
• Check for reinforced handles for added strength.

Broken Mirrors

Swap this for a new mirror. Broken mirrors can be hazardous and should be replaced.

• Look for mirrors with safety backing.
• Consider shatterproof options for added safety.
• Choose a style that fits your decor.

Vacuum Cleaners

Invest in a high-quality vacuum cleaner for effective cleaning. Older models may lack efficiency.

• Check for suction power ratings.
• Consider bagless options for convenience.
• Look for models with multiple attachments for versatility.